Energy Central EnergyPulse Home
Home Subscribe Login Contribute to Energy Pulse Advertise on Energy Pulse About Energy Pulse Feedback to Energy Pulse
Search Articles:   
  You are here: Home > Grid Operations > Article Display


Free Newsletter
Sign up today for your free subscription to the EnergyPulse Weekly Update - delivered directly to your e-mail box.
e-mail:


 

Communicating Smart Meter Value

Sep 9 2010 - 2010-01-01 12:00:00 - Your City

If you are involved in Management or Customer Service and are responsible for communicating the value of smart meters to your utility customers, you don’t want to miss this online discussion - Communicating Smart Meter Value.  more...

Social Media: The new frontier in recruiting, communications and marketing

Sep 13 2010 - 2010-01-01 12:00:00 - Your City

Join social media mavens Matthew Burks and Amanda Shewmake as they provide an insider's perspective on how HR, communications and marketing professionals in energy companies can harness the power of social media to be more effective and productive. more...

Eliminating Obstacles and Delivering the Benefits of the Smart Grid - IBM's Optimized Energy Value Chain (OEVC)

Sep 14 2010 - 2010-01-01 12:00:00 - Your City

The convergence of power and information technologies in the smart grid has created opportunities for finer grained and broader controls of energy flows. These opportunities can improve electric service in multiple dimensions: lower cost, greater reliability, greater customer satisfaction, and more...

Achieving Operational Excellence - What to Consider Before Implementing or Upgrading Your Distribution Management Solutions

Sep 16 2010 - 2010-01-01 12:00:00 - Your City

Significant cost over runs. Changing business requirements. A well thought out plan is essential. Attend this free webcast discussion to hear inside hear three experts in utility operations discuss what utilities need to evaluate when they are considering upgrading or more...

Outsmarting the Smart Grid: IT, Security and Communication Infrastructure  Challenges & Opportunities for Utilities

Sep 21 2010 - 2010-01-01 12:00:00 - Your City

The smart grid is shifting the playing field for utilities. And when the game changes, it pays to be prepared. A nimble solutions partner can help you design the solutions that keep operations on track, even as new challenges come more...

1st CSP Today Concentrated Solar Thermal Power Summit India

Sep 7 2010 - Sep 8 2010 - New Delhi India

Deliver a profitable, productive and commercially successful large scale CSP business in India. Building on the success of past events in USA, Europe & MENA, CSP Today brings to New Delhi the most relevant international experience for the concentrated solar more...

Offshore Wind Energy in North America's Great Lakes Conference

Sep 9 2010 - Sep 10 2010 - Toronto

Two day conference that tackles the most important challenges. A blend of European knowledge from the companies who have been installing offshore wind turbines for the last decade alongside local state governing bodies and leading project developers. Permitting, securing long more...

Autovation 2010

Sep 12 2010 - Sep 15 2010 - Austin, TX - USA

Autovation 2010 is a not-to-miss educational forum that will attract utility executives from around the world looking for new ways to optimize their operations through automation technologies. more...

Global Sustainable Bioenergy North American Convention

Sep 14 2010 - Sep 16 2010 - Minneapolis, MN - USA

The North American convention provides a remarkable opportunity to play a part in guiding renewable energy policy for the 21st century. Attendees will create a resolution that, along with similar resolutions already drafted on four other continents, will help set more...

GridWise Global Forum

Sep 21 2010 - Sep 23 2010 - Washington, DC - USA

Hosted by the GridWise(R) Alliance and the U.S. Department of Energy, the GridWise Global Forum will convene thought leaders from the highest levels of government, business, NGOS, and academia from around the world to discuss the ultimate enabling potential of more...

1. Intro to Nat Gas Trading & Hedging 2. Option Applications in Energy

Sep 20 2010 - Sep 23 2010 - Houston, TX - USA

Introduction to Natural Gas Trading & Hedging - This program provides a comprehensive understanding of the structures that underlie Natural Gas trading. Beyond Essentials: Option Applications in Energy - This course provides a solid practical and conceptual (non-quantitative) understanding of more...

Electric Business Understanding Seminar

Sep 20 2010 - Sep 21 2010 - Houston, TX - USA

Electric Business Understanding provides a comprehensive overview of the electric industry. Position yourself for career advancement by gaining a solid understanding of how the electric business works including key physical, market, and regulatory aspects and how market participants navigate this more...

Electric Market Dynamics Seminar

Sep 22 2010 - Sep 23 2010 - Houston, TX - USA

Electric Market Dynamics offers participants an in-depth understanding of North American electric markets and how they function. Enhance your career by furthering your knowledge of market structures, pricing mechanisms, services offered in markets, and how various participants use the markets more...

Gas and Electric Business Understanding Seminar

Oct 5 2010 - Oct 6 2010 - Los Angeles, CA - USA

Gas and Electric Business Understanding provides a comprehensive overview of the natural gas and electric industries. Position yourself for career success by gaining a solid understanding of how each business works, including key physical, market and regulatory aspects, as well more...

Energy Central
Power Network




Grid Operations


We know you have something to say!
There is an immediate need for articles on the hot topics in the Power Industry! EnergyPulse, like no other publication, also provides a means for our readers to immediately interact with experts like you.
 
Contribute Today!
Please view our Author Guidelines and send submissions to the editor.

Click For More Articles on Grid Operations
 
How Essential is the Smart Grid?
3.10.10   Shehu Khaleel, Electrical Engineer

Article Viewed 2753 Times
14 Comments
E-mail Article Printer Friendly
 
  • Email This Author
  • Comment On Article
  • About The Author
  • More Articles By This Author

    Utility companies generate, transmit and distribute energy to consumers. This can be done more efficiently, cost-effectively and remain sustainable by designing an electric system that integrates smart devices, critical data and two-way communication between the utilities and the consumer-Smart Grid.

    Many argue that Smart Grid is no capable enough to significantly reduce the excessive T&D energy losses. And some argue that the reduction is quite uneconomical compared to the cost of integrating smart grid equipment to decades old grids. Many consider Smart Grid as an incapable innovation especially with the conventional system of power Generation, Transmission and Distribution. Well considering all these argument many start to wonder how essential the Smart Grid is. And various questions are still un-answered to how does Smart Grid reduce energy waste. Its role in renewable energy integration into conventional energy grid, how could smart grid improve energy consumption efficiency.

    Smart grid technologies provide utilities and consumers with real-time knowledge and decision-making tools that will empower them to save energy, resources, money, and the environment. The smart grid is not a product, but rather a collection of hardware and software that works together to make today's grid, well, smarter.

    Overlaying the current power infrastructure with smart grid technology is like connecting the Internet to the computer, making an already useful machine much better and providing people with information to make intelligent decisions. Similarly, the smart grid, or the "energy Internet", empowers consumers, businesses and utilities to make smarter energy choices.

    1. Could it really reduce energy waste?

    Smart grid technologies help improve efficiency by providing the utility with information, so the utility can deliver just what is needed by the consumer and maximize productivity or minimize it depending on the consumption rate. Transmitting more than required power along the lines would expose the lines to more losses, this is due to the complexities of how power is currently delivered.

    These losses take place due to the reactive load, or VArs, and also resistive load, all are functions of the length of the power transmission line. Therefore modern intelligent-grids are equipped with sensors and the sensors are incorporated with capacitors.

    Adding the sensors and capacitors along the line can help compensate for the losses due to reactive load. Capacitors along the line help produce VArs where they're needed to decrease losses.

    2. Does Smart Grid minimize power outages?

    Power outages cost the industrialize Economies more than 450billion USD. Power outage cost US economy more than 100billion dollars alone. And outages normally occur as a result of malfunction of power components along the grid. Transformers are key components of an electric grid. A catastrophic failure of a critical transformer would result in power outages in the downstream network and could cause significant economic and environmental challenges.

    Smart grid technologies help utilities maximize asset performance and reduce unexpected transformer failure and subsequent power outages through alerts, detection, diagnosis, and prognosis. By monitoring different conditions within the transformer, such as gas levels, smart sensors will detect and report potential problems back to the utility in real-time. The information sent to the utility can be stored and analyzed by advanced software, helping predict and prevent potential transformer failure before it happens.

    Smart grid technologies can help intelligently re-route power on the grid to isolate outages and minimize customer impact. Mobile mapping technologies help utilities immediately direct crews to restore power, moving utilities from guessing to knowing.

    3. Renewable energy integration into conventional power grid.

    Smart grid technologies can help reliably integrate variable renewable energy into the grid. When renewable resources are producing electricity, the possibility of congestion on transmission lines can create a barrier to their full utilization. The variability of renewable sources can also cause challenges. And whenever renewables are offline i.e. the wind doesn't blow or it's a cloudy day -- other power generation will be needed to fill in the gaps.

    Fortunately, smart grid technologies can help manage the unpredictability of wind and solar to help alleviate reliability and stability issues caused by power fluctuations. Automated demand response technologies will act as a lever that utilities can pull to help lower demand in the event there is a gap in renewable power generation -- for instance, if the wind stops blowing. To address such contingencies, a utility may incent consumers to opt into programs that allow certain devices (i.e., water heaters) to be temporarily switched off during peak times.

    In the future, storage technologies could also help utilities manage the short-term imbalances in the supply and demand of energy, sometimes caused by the fluctuations of a lot of renewable energy. Batteries will store energy during times of excess wind energy production and discharge that energy via smart grid automation technologies when energy demand exceeds supply.

    4. Smart metering, Grid automation and monitoring

    Smart grid automation technologies, such as distribution management systems and outage management systems, can work in conjunction with smart meters and advanced metering infrastructure to provide real-time knowledge of the grid's status, enabling utilities to prevent trouble before it occurs.

    In advanced applications, monitoring and control technologies -- known as fault diagnosis, isolation and restoration -- can help mitigate the problem before deploying a repair crew. Using monitoring and control software, utilities will be able to identify problems on the grid and automatically reroute power to isolate damage and impact. Technically, these technologies help detect and isolate faulted feeder sections by opening and closing the necessary switches to restore power to the healthy feeder section within seconds. Once isolated, crews will immediately be dispatched to correct any problems.

    Conclusion

    Investing in the smart grid now is a great way to make a "down payment" on the reduction of the global GHG emissions. Improving energy efficiency throughout the grid and increasing the ability of the system to more easily accept non-carbon-based clean energy resources are just two of the ways the smart grid can help now.

    Research indicates that carbon emissions could be reduced by 25% in America if smart grid technologies are implemented. If the grid allowed energy production to be just 5% more efficient, the energy savings would equate to eliminating the fuel and greenhouse gas emissions from 53 million cars.

    Smart grid technologies will also enable higher percentages of centralized and distributed renewable generation to enter the grid efficiently and reliably so they can become significant contributors to the overall global energy platform, helping us reduce the challenges of outages, increase energy efficiency and defer the need to build more energy and power generation infrastructures. Smart grid Technology is of course an essential part of the solution to the global energy crises.

    For information on purchasing reprints of this article, contact Tim Tobeck ttobeck@energycentral.com.
    Copyright 2010 CyberTech, Inc.
     
    Contact The Author
    Email the author
    Phone:
    E-mail Article Printer Friendly
     
  • Click Here For More Articles on Grid Operations


  • Click Here For More Articles By Shehu Khaleel
  • Do you agree or disagree with this article? Send in your own article.

     

    Readers Comments

    Date Comment
    Len Gould
    3.14.10
    In general, a good article, though too shortsighted. In your third point above you state "Batteries will store energy during times of excess wind energy production and discharge that energy via smart grid automation technologies when energy demand exceeds supply." Central battery storage is implied, which is I think missing the boat. Where the future batteries will be is in your customer's PHEV autos (note HYBRID). With just a slightly improved metering system the grid could constantly adjust prices so that willing customers would choose not to charge their cars when the grid is overstressed (due to a lull in wind, lack of sun, a baseload station failure or a grid fault) and possibly even do their morning comutes using bio-fuels or petroleum. Some may even have autos smart enough to return power to the grid, IF the grid were smart enough to fairly compensate them.

    If a utility can pay off the capital on a simple-cycle peaker or a central flow-battery installation by running it perhaps only 100 hours / year then it could save money by paying a very high rate for power from auto batteries for that 100 hours.

    eg. lets assume that the utility needs to earn $50 / kw / year to pay off the capital on the peaker. Then it pays $0.05 / kwh in fuel due to the low efficiency. That means that the power from the peaker is costing them $0.55 / kwh. If my PHEV is capable, on request, of delivering 10 kwh and still provide me enough electric power to barely do my commute. If my programming of the meter system allowed to to deliver to 50 2-hour emergency situations, in a year it could earn me 10 x 50 x $0.55 = $275. If my commute was short (as is common, most time is spent idling in traffic jams), chances are I might not even need to spend any extra on fuel.

    That's where grid engineers and utiliy planners need to be thinking these days.

    Len Gould
    3.14.10
    Of course if you really want to go to the edge, consider IMEUC, my proposed new open market system for electricity.

    Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Part 2 - Market Operation

    Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Part 3 - Alternative Market Operation

    Energy Central Blogs - IMEUC - Independent Market for Every Utility Customer

    Don Hirschberg
    3.16.10
    Off topic.

    Red characters on blue background (as in Len's posting above) are almost impossible for me to read.

    Len Gould
    3.17.10
    Agreed Don, though its not the colour, its the "brightness / intensity" which is the problem. I've tried a lot of different settings, and any which is readable on this site's light blue alternate post backgrounds is practically unreadable on it's dark blue backgrounds.

    Here's some tests. Post a favourite choice.

    Chartreuse Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    CadetBlue Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Aqua Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Ivory Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    DeepPink Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    DarkSeaGreen Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    DarkGoldenRod Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Len Gould
    3.17.10
    Here's some tests on the light background. Post a favourite choice.

    Chartreuse Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    CadetBlue Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Aqua Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Ivory Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    DeepPink Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    DarkSeaGreen Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    DarkGoldenRod Independent Market for Every Utility Customer - Preliminary Business Case

    Jack Ellis
    3.23.10
    Len, I confess I have never read your IMEUC proposal. Based on the title, I suspect our thinking on the topic is quite similar. Thanks for the link.

    Malcolm Rawlingson
    3.24.10
    Much of this article makes little sense.

    "Transmitting more than required power along the lines would expose the lines to more losses, this is due to the complexities of how power is currently delivered."

    If you have figured out a way to transmit more power along a power line than the consumer is requesting please patent it. You'll have beat Einstein and will be an instant millionaire. The whole purpose of the grid is to balance in real time EXACTLY the amount of production with EXACTLY the amount of demand. Electrons are not "sent" they flow due to potential difference and they will only flow when they are demanded by the customer. You cannot send more power down a line than the customers demand.

    Reactive load (VARS) is directly attributable to the use of electric motors and similar devices on the grid. Resistive load (electric heaters) do not create VARS. The ratio of reactive to resistive load is the power factor which can be adjusted at the generator by adjusting the generator field current. Most generators operate as close to PF=1 as possible since this is the most efficient operating mode. The grid already uses capacitor banks to counteract the use of electric motors and similar devices so nothing new there. In addition generators are often used to create reactive power. Usually generators not being used to create megawatts are deployed for this purpose routinely by grid operators.

    "Adding the sensors and capacitors along the line can help compensate for the losses due to reactive load. Capacitors along the line help produce VArs where they're needed to decrease losses."

    The capacitor banks used at grid substations are not some little capacitor you might find on a printed circuit board. They are about the size of a small house. They are already used in every grid system in the world. Not new at all. Been used for about a century.

    In part 2 you talk about monitoring transformers. Not sure of you have ever worked in the power industry but all transformers are routinely monitored for all the things you mentioned. And for the most part this information is already transmitted to grid control centres. Oil in transformers is routinely sampled and changed as required. Transformers are also very reliable and it is extremely rare for a transformer to unexpectedly fail without warning (although it has occurred). Even so most grid substations are able to re-route power around failed devices so there is significant redundancy built in to grid systems. So nothing new there either.

    In item 3 you talk about the variability of wind and solar power. When the wind is not blowing or the Sun is not shining power output from these devices falls - that is trus of course but if the demand is still there another power source will be utilised to maintain the flow of electrons. It is of course the fundamental reason why renewables are not economic. Because you need two power plants...one must be there as a back up when the wind or the Sun is not there. I agree you could control demand and cut off some customers who choose to and you could automatically shutoff air conditioners but turning off small loads isn't going to make a hill of beans difference. Some utilities do that already and you don't need a smart grid to do it.

    So I have not read anything here that is not already done. All grids have sophisticated fault logic for safety and grid stability reasons. Phase to phase and phase to ground will automatically disconnect the line in a cycle or two - if they did not the lines and other components would be damaged. Fault protection is a major feature of all grid systems so nothing new there either.

    So I am still looking for what is new in this article. If this is supposed to be a description of a smart grid then we are already have it.

    Len's idea of charging PHEV's at night or in times of low demand might work - at least in theory. But you would need to change out the whole current stock of automobiles or a significant chunk of it to make much of a difference and of course if you did the peak energy demand would switch from about 5 pm to midnight. Of course battery chargers require transformers and rectifiers to convert the 110 volt AC to 12V DC which introduce VARS into the system which tends to make the grid less efficient. And how exactly does one convert the DC that you have in your car into AC for the grid. You need an inverter. and who is going to pay for millions of those. These are also very inefficient devices.

    Unless by some Len Gould magic people abruptly change their lifestyles I think the concept is a non-starter and not very well thought out.

    Malcolm

    Bob Amorosi
    3.25.10
    Malcolm,

    I agree with most of your comments since I suspect many of the practices you describe about grid operation and control have already been automated to some degree. I suppose some grids in places could use more monitoring and automation to replace manual intervention.

    The one area where smart grid seems to be of large interest to local distribution companies is outage management. Smart meters can be "pinged" through their AMI networks from the utility's head end to more quickly determine exactly where outages are, leading to faster more efficient repairs in the field. The traditional approach in many utilities has been to rely on customer phone calls to report outages.

    I like your last comment - who is going to pay for millions of inverters to feed battery power back into the grid. By extension, who is going to pay for all the smart grid initiatives. Without regulatory reforms, I'm afraid we as consumers will all be paying for it, through much higher utility bills down the road, whether we want any sort of smart grid technology or not in our homes. It’s going to be a tough pill to swallow for many consumers, and in places like Ontario here where the electricity system is highly political and continually tinkered with by legislators, consumers will choke on this bitter pill and show it during future provincial elections.

    Malcolm Rawlingson
    3.25.10
    There are certainly technologies out there that can be used to control demand and, as you say Bob, to make system maintenance easier - especially on large local distribution networks that are common in Canada. The point I was trying to Mr. Khaleel the author was that none of what I read was new and to try to portray the items he noted as somehow "innovative" when we have been using them for years is very misleading. In my view the grid systems we have are already very very smart and extraordinarily reliable.

    It certainly made me wonder whether the author had spent any time in the power industry.

    Regarding the idea of using PHEV's to reverse power the grid. It is one of those nice ideas that seem good in theory but in practice would be a train wreck - and an expensive one at that.

    While storage batteries seem like the solution to intermittent energy supplies from solar and wind the reality is that significant amounts of energy are lost in the conversion from AC to DC and then from DC back to AC and there is no way around it. Apart from this power inverters (those in the tens of kilowatt to megawatt range) - even the most modern solid state ones - are quite noisy and they are not cheap. The hapless PHEV owner would likely have to buy one in addition to his vehicle and a new battery every four years. The few bucks made selling power back to the grid is not likely to cover the cost.

    Also I am not sure that the wave forms produced by inverted DC would be satisfactory for reverse powering the grid. I suspect a lot of devices that are designed to work on a pure sine wave would not work so well on a capacitor clipped wave form. Perhaps Len has some solutions to that.

    One solution is to convert the entire grid to DC. That will only cost a few tens of billions and the need to replace all of the outdated AC appliances with new DC ones will be a stimulus to the economy. (likely the Chinese economy - not ours). I can hear the idea rattling around the halls of power now - it's right up there with windmills at 14c/Kwh and solar at 80c/Kwh.

    Lets call it Green DC - that oughta sell it.

    Malcolm

    Shehu Khaleel
    3.26.10
    Malcom I realy appreciate your comment. And as a professional in the industry I do believe you have some important and educative resources, that would help me to improve my knowledge especially on the Grids automation. Secondly I ve been in the power field for almost 9-years though on a devoloping country where Grid automation is something new. But the article was written long ago. I would be glad to communicate with you please. My email is skhleels@gmail.com. Thank you

    Malcolm Rawlingson
    3.26.10
    Shehu,

    Well I owe you an apology sir

    Please forgive my ignorance. I had written my response based on how the North American and European grid systems are operated. In less developed countries the systems are indeed much less sophisticated and VAR losses are significant because investment in capacitor banks is prohibitively costly.

    From a developing country perspective your article makes much more sense and I do see (now) where you are coming from.

    There are many techniques available to you to improve your system and I will write to you soon to discuss further.

    Once again my sincere apologies for completely misreading your article.

    Malcolm

    Shehu Khaleel
    3.26.10
    Thank you Malcolm, I once more appreciate your comment. I would be looking forward to further discuss with you.

    Len Gould
    3.29.10
    Malcolm: "And how exactly does one convert the DC that you have in your car into AC for the grid. You need an inverter. and who is going to pay for millions of those. These are also very inefficient devices. " -- Tesla has developed the ideal gridwise auto system. When charging batteries, they use the auto's motor(s) as a transformer and its drive electronics as an inverter, meaning the auto constantly carries around its entire charging system, which also happens to be capable of returning DC power from the batteries or generator to the grid as AC at the load rating of the auto's drive inverters. No added cost except for requiring a double- insulated motor, and surprisingly high efficiency. Of course that's too advanced for any large auto manufacturer to implement.... And the auto fleet will likely be entirely PHEV long before your staid old business even tries to identify advantages to encouraging it.

    Len Gould
    3.29.10
    If electric utilities had half the brains of Warren Buffet they would long ago have begun lobbying Washington to buy Tesla's patents into the public domain and encouraging all the large auto mfgrs to implement them.

    Add your comments:
    Please log in to leave a comment!

    Top

        Home | Register | Subscribe | Contribute | Advertise | About Us | Feedback
       Copyright © 2002-2010, CyberTech, Inc. - All rights reserved. Read our Terms of Service.