Energy Central EnergyPulse Home
Home Subscribe Login Contribute to Energy Pulse Advertise on Energy Pulse About Energy Pulse Feedback to Energy Pulse
Search Articles:   
  You are here: Home > Article Display


Free Newsletter
Sign up today for your free subscription to the EnergyPulse Weekly Update - delivered directly to your e-mail box.
e-mail:


 

Distribution Automation & Grid Modernization Business Case Summit 2013

Tuesday May 21, 2013 - Wednesday May 22, 2013 - Charlotte

Distribution Automation, System Hardening & Distributed Generation: Cost Benefit Analysis & Data Analytics To Deliver Reliability & Resiliency more...

Waste Conversion Congress East Coast

Monday Jun 17, 2013 - Tuesday Jun 18, 2013 - Boston, Massachusetts - USA

Deliver a profitable and operational waste conversion project by securing finance, feedstock and approval more...

Data Informed's Marketing Analytics and Customer Engagement

Monday Jun 24, 2013 - Tuesday Jun 25, 2013 - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - USA

Data Informed´s Marketing Analytics and Customer Engagement provides marketing, sales, and customer support managers with the information they need to create an effective data-driven customer strategy. more...

Legal Essentials for Utility Executives

Monday May 20, 2013 - Saturday May 25, 2013 - 8:30 AM Eastern - Stowe, Vermont - USA

Legal Essentials for Utility Executives: May 19 to 25, 2013 and October 6 to 12, 2013 This rigorous, two-week course will provide electric utility executives with the legal foundation to more fully understand the utility regulatory framework, the role of more...


 OR 


We know you have something to say!
There is an immediate need for articles on the hot topics in the Power Industry! EnergyPulse, like no other publication, also provides a means for our readers to immediately interact with experts like you.
 
Contribute Today!
Please view our Author Guidelines and send submissions to the editor.

 
Deriving BioSynthetic Fuel from Genetically Engineered Crops
4.26.06   Harry Valentine, Commentator/Energy Researcher, Langson Energy

Article Viewed 737 Times
4 Comments
 
  • Email This Author
  • Comment On Article
  • About The Author
  • More Articles By This Author

    Concerns about the long-term supply of oil have prompted both governments and industries to explore development of renewable and alternative fuels. During the oil crisis of the early 1970's, America and the world became acutely aware that the world supply of fossil oil could be finite. Future oil prices are expected to rise as production eventually declines while demand remains high. Plant-based oil and synthetic oils have become the leading alternative oils to fossil oil. Synthetic oil first appeared in Germany during World War 2 when the Fischer-Tropsch process was developed to produce liquid combustible fuel from coal. The process was refined further at the Sasolburg complex in South Africa to produce liquid fuel and pharmaceuticals from coal.

    A refinement of the Fischer-Tropsh process is being used at several locations around the world to produce synthetic diesel fuel from natural gas. While the price of synthetic fuel is presently high, its future price is expected to decline as production increases and world crude oil prices rise. Over the long-term, the unsubsidized price of synthetic diesel and biodiesel could become price-competitive with fossil-derived diesel fuel. The recent discovery of extensive beds of methyl hydrate on the sea floor off the American coast could provide the synthetic fuel industry with a secure resource from which to mass-produce synthetic diesel fuel and other liquid fuels in the future.

    The influential American environmental movement strongly opposes offshore drilling for oil and natural gas in what they regard to be prime (marine) wildlife habitat. As a result, environmental considerations may place higher emphasis on the production of fuel that is derived from plants such as soy and canola. However, looming shortages of fresh water are becoming problematic for many countries and may curtail the future of agriculture in some regions. Climate change may be causing deserts in some countries to expand. It may be possible to slow or stop the increasing rate of desertification by growing drought-resistant plants in some desert areas or by cultivating plantations of saline-resistant plants that can survive on ocean water.

    New techniques are being developed in genetic engineering that could increase the resistance of a range of viable biofuel plants to saline water, drought, insects and disease. Genes from saline-tolerant plants such as Ironweed, Beach Plum, Sea Grass and Mangrove could be transferred into suitable plant species to enable them to remove salt via salt bladders or filter salt at the roots when grown using ocean water. Managed plantations of commercially viable and saline-resistant plants could be cultivated in desert areas that are located near the ocean. The biofuel industry would periodically harvest the mature plants to extract oil and process the leftover material into ethanol.

    A precedent for a saline-resistant plantation exists on the Kenyan coast and was begun over 30-years ago by French agronomist Rene Halle. A variety of saline tolerant plants that were compatible with each other and that supported each other were planted in an organized layout on a bed of dead coral. Example, some plants contributed nitrogen to the 'soil' while other plants used the nitrogen. Within a decade, a thriving small forest that was sustained mainly by ocean water was growing of the bed of coral. Rene Halle's precedent could serve as a basis for ocean water to be used to grow viable crops for the biofuel industry in desert regions and similar non-agricultural areas that are located near the ocean. Suitable locations would include:

    • Mojave Desert Regions of the Southwestern United States
    • Regions of the Sahara Desert in Northern Africa
    • Areas of the desert regions in Northern Yemen and Northern Oman
    • Areas of the Atacama Desert of Chile and Peru
    • Areas of the Vizcaino Desert of Mexico
    • Southern areas of the Mojave Desert in Mexico near the Gulf of California
    • Areas of the desert regions of Southwestern and Northwestern Australia
    • Areas of the Namib Desert of Namibia in Southern Africa.

    Plantations of viable biofuel crops could be grown in desert regions and serve as barriers to stop advancing deserts from threatening arable lands upon which food crops for human consumption are grown. These plantations could offer numerous direct and indirect benefits that may include:

    • Provide oil and ethanol to sustain a viable biofuel industry
    • Provide fuel resources to sustain transportation services
    • Sustain textile industries (fibre from insect-resistant plants)
    • Sustain pharmaceutical industries (fertilizers, drugs)
    • Sustain downstream economic activity related to the above industries
    • Contain the advance of desertification
    • Moderate the effects of desert climates at nearby populated areas
    • Provide habitat and protection for select species of wildlife
    • Protect lands on which human food crops are grown
    • Provide livelihoods and sustain human population centers.

    Biofuel crops may be grown on land (deserts), on the sea floor or on the ocean surface. The prolific plant growth that now infests the floor of the Mediterranean Sea is an example of an ocean-based undersea fuel crop. This type of undersea agriculture could be expanded and managed in shallow coastal waters or in specially formed lagoons located near the ocean in warm tropical climates. Oceanic plants such as sea grass or suitable genetically modified plants could be grown in such areas or even in inland depressions that could be flooded with ocean water. The Qattara Depression in Egypt and a similar depression in Eritrea have land elevations that are below sea level and could be flooded with ocean water. Such plants would periodically be harvested for processing into ethanol.

    Ocean-based biofuel crops also may be cultivated on the ocean surface in the warmer regions of the world. The plants may either float on the ocean surface like Sargasso weed or be grown in extensive arrays of interlinked floating containers. Plants have long been grown in containers that floated on bodies of fresh water in Southern China. This concept could be developed for ocean use and involve arrays of containers that would be held in place by cables that are anchored either to coastal locations or to the sea floor. Certain varieties of oceanic plants could be cultivated in arrays of floating containers and would require little or no genetic modification. Other types of plants may need to be especially genetically modified for such cultivation. Both types of plants may be cultivated by suppliers to the biofuel industry and harvested as a resource for them.

    There are several bodies of ocean water in tropical regions that may be suitable locations where such ocean-based agriculture may be practiced:

    • Gulf of California and its bays and inlets, Gulf of Campeche and Lago de Terminos, Chetumal Bay (Mexico)
    • Grand Bahama Bank (Bahamas)
    • Bay around Isle de la Gonave and northwest of Port au Prince (Haiti)
    • Gulf of Darien (Panama)
    • Golfo Dulce, Gulf of Nicoya and Lago de Chiriqui (Costa Rica)
    • Golfo de Guacanyabo (Cuba)
    • Golfo de Paria, Golfo Venezuela and Lake Maracaibo (Venezuela)

    Suitable international locations to grow oceanic biofuel plants would include:

    • Southern Mediterranean Sea
    • Red Sea, Persian Gulf (Middle East)
    • Gulf of Kutch, Gulf of Cambay (India)
    • Gulf of Thailand and Bight of Bangkok (Thailand)
    • South Coast of Madura Island, Gulf of Tomini and Gulf of Bone (Indonesia)
    • Gulf of Tonking (Vietnam)
    • Geelvink Baai and Gulf of Bintuni (Papua New Guinea)
    • Davao Gulf and Moro Gulf (Philippines)
    • Gulf of Carpentaria, Joseph Bonaparte Gulf & Van Diemen Gulf (Australia)

    Plants that may be grown on the surface of warm ocean at the aforementioned locations may be suitable for processing into ethanol or other fuels. The biofuel industry is presently refining the phenomena known as "jungle rot" so that they could produce ethanol from a wide range of organic material including plants grown on the ocean floor or on its surface. A wide variety of organic materials can be used as a resource for this process. Alternatively, land-grown and ocean-grown organic materials could be rapidly decayed to release methane that would be processed into synthetic diesel fuel via the Fischer-Tropsch process. Methods are presently being researched in which organically derived ethanol or methanol could be processed into synthetic oils and gasoline.

    Conclusions

    It is conceivable that mass-produced synthetic fuel, biofuel and biosynthetic fuel could eventually become cost-competitive against fuel derived from crude oil and even do so without need for special tax incentives or state subsidies. Such an event would likely occur if no new significant deposits of crude oil are discovered within the next 2-decades. It is likely that in the long-term future, more fuel and oil will be derived from genetically modified biofuel crops that are grown using ocean water. Such crops could be grown on non-agricultural land in desert areas that are near the ocean, on the ocean surface or on the sea floor. They would likely come to play a significant role to sustain the economy of several nations where the future supply of potable water could become severely constrained.

    Genetically-modified plants that grow on land (deserts) using ocean water would need to be supplied with fresh ocean water (and nutrients) through extensive underground piping systems. Modern excavation methods would be used to install the extensive piping systems in hot climates. If the roots filter of the genetically modified plants are able to filter out salt, the underground piping systems would need be designed so as to continually remove excess salt and return it to the sea. The same type of piping systems may be used if the plants have salt bladders that continually deposit salt on the ground surface. Methods may be developed to continually harvest the salt that may then be sold into local or nearby markets. Proper preservation and management of the land on which biofuel crops are grown would ensure the long-term viability of the activity.

    For information on purchasing reprints of this article, contact sales.
    Copyright 2013 CyberTech, Inc.
     
    Contact The Author
    Email the author
     
  • Click Here For More Articles on Fossil & Biomass


  • Click Here For More Articles By Harry Valentine
  • Do you agree or disagree with this article? Send in your own article.

     

    Readers Comments

    Date Comment
    Jonathan Overly
    5.2.06
    Mr. Valentine, Just wanted to say that I appreciate your research, articles and information on alternatives to the current energy systems. Thanks!

    Berol Robinson
    5.2.06
    I have two comments:

    1. The same people who object to off-shore drilling will likely object to strewing genetically modified plants all over the oceans and deserts.

    2. How much solar energy can you expect to convert to motor fuel this way? Even a very approximate calculation would be useful.

    After all, we shall have used in a period of a (few) hundred years the fossil fuel which has been laid down for us over a period of, say, 100 million years: inefficiently, to be sure, but still an accumulation over eons.

    If we could get 1% of present consumption (80 million barrels a day), then it becomes interesting.

    Berol Robinson 1, rue du Général Gouraud 92190 MEUDON France téléphone: 01 46 26 02 05 (from France) +331 4626 0205 (from elsewhere) eMail: berol.robinson@chello.fr

    The writer is an American physicist (AB Harvard '48, PhD Hopkins '53) and retired science and science education officer of UNESCO - the United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization. He is a member of the Association des Ecologistes Pour le Nucléaire (AEPN) and president of its American affiliate Environmentalists For Nuclear Energy (EFN-USA). He drives a Prius. Website www.ecolo.org

    EFN is a not-for-profit international organization gathering more than 8000 members and supporters, with a network of similar organizations and of local correspondents in more than 50 countries. Its purpose is to inform the public on energy and the environment.

    EFN-USA is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt not-for-profit organization incorporated in the United States, with similar objectives.

    mauk mcamuk
    5.15.06
    Hello!

    While I appreciate the appeal of biofuels, I find that I cannot overlook the fact that in order to displace a significant portion of our current (and especially future) energy needs, we will need to increase the net primary production of the entire planet by a considerable amount.

    Now, while this is certainly POSSIBLE, I worry about the impact. I direct your attention to this article:

    http://www.spacedaily.com/news/energy-tech-03zp.html

    For more depth, may I refer you to:

    http://bioenergy.ornl.gov/papers/misc/energy_conv.html

    http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf

    While it is probable that biofuels will serve an important niche use, I feel that the biosystem should be preserved for the production of food. Everybody neds to eat, and I would never want to face the choice of starving a child in the Third World to fill up my tank.

    Instead, to supply primary power humanity needs to concentrate on nuclear energy in all its forms. Today the most efficient way to do this entails nuclear fission, windmills, and hydropower.

    Also, I feel that extracting useful energy from waste streams would be a considerable advance. The First World is abusively wasteful, and any project that operates in those vast waste streams strikes me as a great idea. The recent success of the infamous "turkey guts" plant is a very hopeful sign, and the huge amounts of agri-business waste may provide a considerable source of biofuels in the moderate future, while having little impact on the ecosystem.

    For info on that pilot plant, see:

    http://www.changingworldtech.com/

    Roger Arnold
    5.16.06
    Now, while this is certainly POSSIBLE, I worry about the impact. I direct your attention to this article:

    http://www.spacedaily.com/news/energy-tech-03zp.html

    That article is interesting, in an academic way, but what's the point? All is shows is that process by which oil was made in nature was extremely inefficient, in terms of the fraction of dead plant matter that ended up in the right conditions to get converted. Says nothing about how much biomass is needed to produce a barrel of synthetic oil today.

    If the energy to make synthetic fuels is supplied externally--e.g., from wind, nuclear, or solar energy as opposed to partial combustion of the biomass--the carbon efficiency of the conversion can be 100%. In that case, you find that current wastes--agriculture, timber operations, and urban--are nearly enough to supply our transportation fuel needs.

    Add your comments:
    Please log in to leave a comment!

    Top

    Sponsored Content
        Home | Register | Subscribe | Contribute | Advertise | About Us | Feedback
       Copyright © 2002-2013, CyberTech, Inc. - All rights reserved. Read our Terms of Service.